Frequency Division Duplex
FDD requires two separate
communications channels. Wireless systems need two separate frequency
bands or channels. A sufficient amount
of guard band separates the two bands so the transmitter and receiver don’t
interfere with one another. Good filtering or duplexers and possibly shielding
are a must to ensure the transmitter does not desensitize the adjacent receiver.
In
a cell phone with a transmitter and receiver operating simultaneously within
such close proximity, the receiver must filter out as much of the transmitter
signal as possible. The greater the spectrum separation, the more effective the
filters.
Time Division Duplex
TDD
uses a single frequency band for both transmit and receive. Then it shares that
band by assigning alternating time slots to transmit and receive operations (Fig. 3).
The information to be transmitted—whether it’s voice, video, or computer
data—is in serial binary format. Each time slot may be 1 byte long or could be
a frame of multiple bytes.
Because
of the high-speed nature of the data, the communicating parties cannot tell
that the transmissions are intermittent. The transmissions are concurrent
rather than simultaneous. For digital voice converted back to analog, no one
can tell it isn’t full duplex.
In
some TDD systems, the alternating time slots are of the same duration or have
equal DL and UL times. However, the system doesn’t have to be 50/50
symmetrical. The system can be asymmetrical as required.
For instance, in
Internet access, download times are usually much longer than upload times so
more or fewer frame time slots are assigned as needed. Some TDD formats offer
dynamic bandwidth allocation where time-slot numbers or duration are changed
on the fly as required.
The
real advantage of TDD is that it only needs a single channel of frequency
spectrum. Furthermore, no spectrum-wasteful guard bands or channel separations
are needed. The downside is that successful implementation of TDD needs a very
precise timing and synchronization system at both the transmitter and receiver
to make sure time slots don’t overlap or otherwise interfere with one another.
Applications :
Most cell-phone
systems use FDD. The newer LTE and 4G systems use FDD. Cable TV systems are
fully FDD.
Most
wireless data transmissions are TDD. WiMAX and Wi-Fi use TDD. So does Bluetooth
when piconets are deployed. ZigBee is TDD. Most digital cordless telephones use
TDD.
Conclusion
TDD
appears to be the better overall choice, but FDD is far more widely implemented
because of prior frequency spectrum assignments and earlier technologies. FDD
will continue to dominate the cellular business for now. Yet as spectrum
becomes more costly and scarce, TDD will become more widely adopted as spectrum
is reallocated and repurposed.
Tabular differences :
Tabular differences :